Foreign Policy

5

comments

Khalilzad Speaks on Obama’s Afghan Plan

November 24, 2009 - 12:16 PM | by: Reena Ninan

‬‪‪ ‬‬‬‪‪As President Obama continues to deliberate about whether to send more U.S. troops to Afghanistan, Fox News Middle East Correspondent Reena Ninan sat down with former U.S. ambassador to Afghanistan Zalmay Khalilzad, who has been working behind the scenes to advise U.S. policymakers on the issue.

Excerpts:‬‬‪‪ ‬‬‪‪ ‬‬‪‪

Ninan: President Obama is mulling how many troops to send to Afghanistan. I've seen multiple plans that would boost troop numbers from anywhere between 10,000 and 40,000. What's your advice?‬‬‪‪ ‬‬‪‪

Khalilzad: General McChrystal has talked about 40,000. He's talked about a counter-insurgency strategy and he believes he needs those forces to conduct an effective counter-insurgency strategy. I would take his advice. As a commander, he was given an assignment and now he has come back saying [that] in order for him to do his job, this is what he needs. I would give that great weight.‬‬‪‪ ‬‬‪‪ I would think the civilian side talking about how much military force is needed is like asking a medical doctor about the requirements for an agricultural problem. I think the embassy has an appropriate role, clearly, to weigh-in on the strategy. But its focus ought to be more [on] the civilian requirements--in terms of what we can do to make the Afghan government more effective.‬‬‪‪ ‬‬‪‪

Ninan: One thing the White House has been saying to Karzai is that he needs to crack down on corruption. How should he do that?‬‬‪‪ ‬‬‪‪

Khalilzad: Well, one of the weaknesses of the current situation is that our ability to influence President Karzai to do what is in his interest, and the interest of Afghanistan, has been very limited. It's very important now that he is reelected that trust is reestablished. And the way to do that is not by publicly hectoring him. I think he's a proud person and he will react negatively.‬‬‪‪ ‬‬‪‪ When I was there for the two years as ambassador, I had a very good and effective relationship with President Karzai. So it can be done. But trust needs to be restored. Trust has been damaged between the administration and President Karzai.‬‬‪‪ ‬‬‪‪

Ninan: What constitutes "winning" in a place like Afghanistan?‬‬‪‪ ‬‬‪‪

Khalilzad: Success means an Afghanistan that can increasingly stand on its own feet--an Afghanistan that is not a source of extremism and terror.‬‬ ‪‪ ‬‬‪‪ If extremists win in Afghanistan or in Pakistan, it will transform this region as a whole. It will bolster extremists and terrorists across this region and would pose a major challenge to the rest of the world, increase the threat to the United States, [and]undermine American credibility. We cannot afford that. The alternative will be quite dangerous not only for the people of the area, but for this entire region, including the rest of the world, and the United States.‬‬‪‪

alberto bitar

He is a 100% narcissist. I just heard on Fox that he will deliver a 40 minutes speech at West Point next week during prime time. I don't care the time. anytine he shows on TV I move to TCM. I think he sleeps with as microphone and Michelle must be sleeping on Lincoln bedroom. He doesn't have any experience at all. The best description about his economics knowledge is that he never had even had a lemonade stand. And regarding his oratory skills he couldn't clean the boots of Fidel. And I came from Cuba in 1968. I know what socialism is.

November 25, 2009 at 11:18 PM
Reply

Steve S.

Obviously Nazario - you have "quaffed" down the Kool Aid and once again use the tired, pathetic "Blame Bush" refrain to try and explain away this incompetent, big eared, Marxist liar. He is a pathetic little man being advised by equally pathetic losers like Hillary and Axelgeek. He, just like all you liberal cowards only speak of "exit strategies" and never of victory - the unending mantra of the spineless.

November 25, 2009 at 6:50 AM
Reply

CarolynsVoice

Due to cancer 12 years ago, I can not speak (not even a whisper). The only way to help our Country, I found is to write a one page blog. Somewhere that folks like me, could get the news in a page, (or 3). I know of no one in the military now. I have been telling my readers what a discrace it is having out pres. be such a liar that when he was campaign ing, he said that he would do anything it took to win in Afghanistan. Like everything else HE LIED. I've done 14 blogs in a month. I research every one. We can not let Khalilzad down. I've said it all in my blog, and will continue to. Please read it. I have not had the time to get a .com or .org up a running. I am a staff of 1. Please read it. I am at CarolynsVoice.blogspot.com. You can also reach me at Carolyntalking@gmail.com. Thank you

November 24, 2009 at 3:16 PM
Reply