U.S.

Steve Harrigan

Miama, FL

89

comments

Puerto Rican Coffee Farms Need Workers

November 23, 2009 - 4:10 PM | by: Steve Harrigan

In a time of massive layoffs, there are some jobs that nobody in Puerto Rico wants.

Puerto Rico has the highest unemployment in the U.S., at 17 percent, and that number will go higher if the government carries out plans to lay off 30,000 employees. At the same time, coffee plantations are desperate for workers. When the governor recently suggested people pick coffee, many considered it an insult.

The coffee plantations are struggling to get enough workers, even after throwing in free transportation and meals. Plantation owners are now using convict labor, with buses taking the prisoners to the fields and back each day.

An entrepreneur who spoke to Fox News said Puerto Ricans have become too dependent on the state and look down on agriculture as something backward. He has plans for agri-tourism. He got his start selling fresh orange juice to hotels.

It's not easy work. Coffee is grown on hillsides to allow the water to run off. Coffee beans are berries first, sweet. Coffee pickers here make about $75 on a good day, at about $8 an hour. They pick during rainy season, so in the dense leaves it is always wet, and with the mud on a hillside it is slippery. Mosquitos bite, leaving a small red circle as if you have been stuck by a pin.

We watch a coffee picker removing the red beans from a plant. His thumbs and forefingers move rapidly and gently at the same time, taking the red, leaving the green. It reminded me of someone typing on a Blackberry, but it was a real berry instead.

RobotMan

It's interesting to read the comments. I just want to say a couple of things as a small businessman. I spend much of my time in the island, invest there and find much opportunity there even the the current dismal economic conditions. First let me say that Puerto Ricans are, for the most part, some of the warmest, kindest, most helpful people I've ever met. There are many aspects of their family-centered and less materialistic culture that we could learn from. But it continually troubles me to see that in many respects, their society is on the wrong track -- the same wrong track that the US is on but PR is further along. In my humble opion opinion, they are not lacking all work ethic but woefully lacking initiative (tip of the hat to Michael the CubanRican who nailed this earlier) and any kind of entrepreneuial know-how. They are -- cheifly because of their media -- distracted by 1)--blaming the US for their problems and 2)--debating whether they should be a state, remain as they are, or be indepentdent -- in which case they would quickly devolve into a little Cuba. They do not realize that they really have the best of both worlds right now...they have economic freedom but w/o the level of meddling by Uncle Sam. If Fortuño can get his agenda enacted, that is really the island's only hope of restoring their dignity and prosperity. The question is whether the unions and media will rerail it before it has a chance to pan out. Some of them may need to pick coffee but they should be proud to do it -- and ashamed to sit collecting benefits at the expense of others.

November 26, 2009 at 11:38 AM
Reply

Miguel semidey

Aqui hay doce millones de ilegales haciendo el trabajo que los blancos y los afroamericanos no quierren hacer de que uds. hablan.Por que cuando necesitan mil soldados van a buscarlos a PR y no van a Mexico por eso las ayudas no hay nada por nada. Un boricua orgulloso de ser PUERTORIQUENO .

November 25, 2009 at 2:27 PM
Reply

Thomas Rios

Dear Sirs I have nothing but utmost respect for your broadcasts and journalist reporting, however, on Monday 11/23, my confidence was shaken when this story was aired by Shep. Someone did not check their maps and misplaced the island of Puerto Rico using the island of the Dominican Republic to identify the location of San Juan. It's akin to using the state of Pennsylvania to demarcate the location of Newport, Rhode Island. I hope something is done to correct this error, as most people do not know where Puerto Rico is located and can be mislead by this report.

November 25, 2009 at 12:30 PM
Reply

Florence Jimenez

Comentarios simplistas y llanas a situaciones complicadas y problemas profundos. / Simplistic and shallow commentaries for deep and very complicated situations. We have many social problems in Puerto Rico, but they are not much different from the ones I see everyday in the US news.

November 25, 2009 at 7:45 AM
Reply

Abner Feal

There is some truth is the commentaries, yet there are factors behind the scene that most be account. To fully describe that Puerto Rican living in the Island are lazy and mean people is false. Never the less there are people who are not willing to work and take advantage or the welfare system. Puerto Rico was transform from an agriculture base economy without welfare into a manufacturing/service oriented economy with welfare. The evil of welfare has demoralize worker, were by it provides an incentive for people not to work but depend on Uncle Sam. In addition, you have a class of skill educated work force that has been train on business administration, engineering, medical and education. Agriculture work such as picking coffee beans does not require college education or technical skill learn in a trade work (i.e. mechanic). To insist that a skill labor force that has face unprecedented layoff be use on an agriculture industry is unrealistic. On the other hand the welfare effect as I mention before give a de-incentive on low paid jobs. Mentally a person on welfare is better off not working at a minimum wage job. The welfare effect has created a parasite population of incapable citizens who depend totally on Uncle Sam. Another factor that also contribute to the dilemma is an unsolved political status (this issue is a joke, Washington has miss use power and lack democracy at home) has demoralize people interest in re-investing at home. The issue on Puerto Rico can not be look on a single lense, but most be observe from many lenses.

November 24, 2009 at 5:59 PM
Reply

Fernando B

One funny thing happened....Dominicans are actually the ones picking coffee in at a site in Lares. Why? The Puerto Rican owner WILL NOT hire Puerto Ricans. Just like the fellow below commented about the Costa Ricans using Nicaraguans, or the US using Mexicans, its illegal immigration the one driving this too, that is, a Puerto Rican earning $10 an hour is better off being a Welfare recipient than working. The other fellow born in PR but who has lived most of his life in the US KNOWS and DESCRIBED IT like it is: People are rude, don't care and have attitude. Actually it is a MINORITY the ones who really work hard and carry the load for the rest.

November 24, 2009 at 10:32 AM
Reply

Wil-Q

PR has always been a country full of lazy people! USA consider them nothing, so that Fox news displayed San Juan De La Maguana in DR instead of the main city of PR!

November 24, 2009 at 7:47 AM
Reply

nelsom

I am a Puerto Rican living in the US since I was 1 year old in 1965. I am now 45.Lived in Puerto Rico from 1998 to 2007 and can honestly say were the worst years of my life.Puerto Rico has no customer service very often you are treated like crap at the stores you shop(like they are doing you a favor)There is no such thing as an appointment you make one and when you arrive they tell you it's first come first serve your 8 am appointment turns into an all day affair and I do me all day.You go to get a drivers license and the drug addicts are outside waiting to usher you to the mobil homes, set up around the area as Drs.office for your physical another for your 2x2 photos another with the payment stamps you need for your transaction, and yet another with photo copy facilities as you also need to provide DTOP with all copies as they will not do it( an easy way to forge documents).This situation has happened before in the Green pepper, tomato, mango,onion and many other fields the products rot as no one wants to work no matter what they are offered to do so.I remember one time when they were offered as much as $10 an hour and people would say $10 an hour in the sun NO WAY!!Don't even get me started on the rudeness of drivers.Despierta Puerto Rico

November 24, 2009 at 7:23 AM
Reply

Michael- The CubanRican

This saddens me but it is a fact: Puerto Ricans collectively have completly lost the sense of work ethic. But it goes deeper than that, the reason Puerto Ricans have lost this work ethic is because of their poltical dependency. Puerto Ricans were mostly rural folks, you owned your land and you had to toil for food, shelter and clothing. Puerto Ricans no longer live with this mentaliy, and its all because of undignified social welfare. When you can take the easy road, the majority of people( not just in Puerto Rico) will take it. Vote Republican and lets re-learn the golden word: Initiative.

November 24, 2009 at 7:19 AM
Reply

Armando

Before being too hard on Puerto Ricans who are not picking coffee, know that this phenomenon is not unique to Puerto Rico. In Costa Rica, which has a major coffee industry that has helped boost that country's economy, Costa Ricans stopped picking coffee and now it is migrant poor Nicaraguans who do the picking (they have a migration problem in Costa Rica too). And you don't even have to go that far to see this phenomenon. RIght here in the U.S., it is the migrant poor workers who do the menial jobs, from the fields of California to cleaning offices in major cities like NY and DC. The poor mainland U.S. citizens apparently refuse to do those jobs too. For those of you who say you want to go pick coffee in PR, know that these types of jobs also exist in the mainland if you really want to take a menial job where you have to physically break your back every day. As anyone who has worked with Puerto Ricans knows, we are as hard-working and industrious as any other people.

November 24, 2009 at 6:39 AM
Reply

Dav2670

I have never been to PR but I date a PR-woman. It is sad to hear first hand the stories she tells of the corruption, violence and lawlessness her family experiences there. What is even worse is to hear her family here (as well as her)speak so negative of America and how we cause most of the problems through out the world, including PR. What ever happened to taking ownership in your actions as well as a hard days pay for a hard days work!

November 24, 2009 at 6:29 AM
Reply

Fernando B

An Idependent Puerto Rico: The next Cuba, the next Castro, the new "balseros" (rafters fleeing the island), the new enemies of the USA, the new sponsors and allies of Chavez, Iran and North Korea. Yeap, that is what waits for those who believe that Puerto Rican Citizenship is legit (The Spaniards had possesion for 400 years, the Yanks for 100, and before all of them, it was the Taino Indians), something which has NEVER existed. And what can Puerto Rico produce? Not much...It is a shame that such a beautiful Island is saddled with such a large group of useless worms sucking on other's fruits and labor (through our taxes). Puerto Rican pride is nowadays as hollow as Madonna swiping her butt with the PuertoRican flag (it did happen).

November 24, 2009 at 2:47 AM
Reply

Fernando B

Hey Independentistas! Now you can keep the Island! To the few real working people, the time to leave is now, the USA awaits for you, before they a time limit is imposed for a choice of Citizenship to keep, which BTW, for those of you who must know, a Marxist Leader in Puerto Rico was awarded Puerto Rican Citizenship (non-US) by the highest court in that land, due to the scumbag lawyers who control the Island, the "Colegio de Abogados". Hey USA, STOP wasting your money in Puerto Rico! Let them keep their country and have them drown in their own excremental pride of useless hollow nothingness....Which is to say let Puerto Rico take the next step in doing the Welfare State switch to an Independent Socialist welfare state with their own worthless currency (the Puerto Rican Peso?) and the biggest reduction in standard of living in the recent history of the World! Yipee!

November 24, 2009 at 2:30 AM
Reply

Jay

Well stated. If they don't want statehood let them become like the Phillipines. See if they are better off in 10 years having to support themselves.

November 24, 2009 at 1:51 AM
Reply

Francisco Rodriguez

What I want to know is when America will wakeup and quit sending tax dollars to support welfare in PR where NO ONE pays federal income tax. Yes, you heard that right, all the benefits of being a US citizen but no federal taxes!!! Such a deal! It was embarassing to me when I grew up there and I never understood outside of Ramey AFB (now closed) and Roosevelt Roads/Vieques (faltering/abandoned) why the federal government would extend it's captive breeding program to an overpopulated territory. No, PR doesn't vote in Presidential elections, does not have Senators nor Representatives in Congress (just a "resident comissioner" that is pretty useless) so even the political motivation makes no sense.

November 24, 2009 at 1:10 AM
Reply

Fernando B

Puerto Rico is the "Welfare" State of the US, unlike the States. 50% of the population is on some sort of welfare....30% of the population works for the Government and the services are the worst. The Middle Class pays over $400 of electricity because they use mostly oil as their source of energy...Besides getting billions of dollars in US aide and not paying Income (only FICA) taxes to the IRS and have their own tax collecting agency (Departamento de Hacienda)that collects additional revenue in order to make up for the excessive bureaucracy, not to mention a recently added sales tax. There are over 500,000 Puertorricans in the Orlando area (not NewYoRicans) who have "bought" their Statehood since the opposition favors the Status Quo and the Liberal Lawyers control and plunder the Island.

November 24, 2009 at 1:10 AM
Reply

mo

So true

November 24, 2009 at 12:59 AM
Reply

murli advani

no welfare or unemployment for those able to pick coffee beans. Make the bums work for a living.

November 24, 2009 at 12:25 AM
Reply

Socopower

Unfortunately there too much 'Conformismo' (comfort with little) in the island. It is too easy to not work and get paid .... they got it good...

November 24, 2009 at 12:25 AM
Reply

rod griffis

tomorrow realy doesnt mean tomorrow thats the problem try working as a professional in P.R. took 1 year to renew nursing license after having one for years. teach english in school its a great second language to have in Ameica

November 24, 2009 at 12:22 AM
Reply