Fox News - Fair & Balanced
Search Site

Wednesday, April 7, 2010 as of 11:14 AM ET


Alicia Acuna

Denver, CO


Heene Parents Plead Guilty to Hoax

November 13, 2009 - 11:17 AM | by: Alicia Acuna

Update on Friday, November 13 at 9:13 a.m. local:

Mayumi Heene’s defense attorney says many reasons went into her decision to plead guilty to a misdemeanor of false reporting, including the possibility of losing at trial and being convicted of a felony and as a Japanese citizen she could then face deportation.  The Class Three misdemeanor carries a penalty of up 6 months in jail, although the judge stated the agreement indicates a probationary sentence for Mayumi.  Judge also advised her she may have to make restitution in the amount he would deem appropriate.  Her sentencing is also set for December 23, 2009 at 9 a.m. local.

Update on Friday, November 13 at 9:00 a.m. local

Mayumi Heene now appearing before the judge.  The judge just advised her that the plea could lead to her deportation, denial of reentry to the U.S. or it could interfere with her naturalization.  The judge says no one can guarantee it to her, citizenship is a federal issue.  The judge also checked with both parents to make sure their minds are clear and that they’re not on any medications which could impact their ability to understand proceedings.

Update on Friday, November 13 at 8:50 a.m. local:

Richard Heene’s sentencing set for Wednesday, December 23, 2009.  His lawyer is asking to handle it over the phone (in private) due to the media crush.  Defense attorney David Lane also pointed out that his client is pleading guilty to avoid his wife, Mayumi’s deportation to Japan.  Richard Heene can leave the state to seek employment.

The parents made infamous by a giant errant balloon and an estimated 2-million-dollar chase to find their son will be in a Colorado courtroom tomorrow to admit it was all a hoax. David Lane, the defense attorney for Richard Heene released the following statement today saying the couple will cop a plea. Meantime, the sheriff in the case Jim Alderden will not be charged with releasing case information to the media. According to his office, there will be no reaction on the pleas by the Heene family because he is, “…on a well deserved vacation and cannot be reached for comment.”

Here’s a copy of Richard Heene’s defense attorney statement:

November 12, 2009

Re: The Heene Case

Guilty Pleas

On November 13, 2009, at 8:30 a.m., Richard and Mayumi Heene will enter pleas of guilty in Larimer County Court.

Mayumi Heene will plead guilty to False Reporting to Authorities, a class 3 misdemeanor (the lowest level misdemeanor in Colorado law) with a stipulated sentence of probation.

Richard Heene will plead guilty to Attempting to Influence a Public Servant, a class 4 felony. The prosecutor has stipulated to a sentence of probation.

The stipulations carry the possibility of up to 90 days in jail for Richard and 60 days for Mayumi along with the probation. After pleas are entered the sentencing will be continued for approximately one month for the preparation of pre-sentence reports.


Mayumi Heene is a citizen of Japan. As such, any felony conviction or certain misdemeanors would result in her deportation, even though her husband and children are Americans. Because Mayumi, while being questioned by law enforcement made certain statements which the prosecutor could use against her to possibly obtain a felony conviction and thus, her deportation by the federal government, she is avoiding that possibility with this plea.. Unfortunately, the prosecutors insisted upon a package deal where Richard would have to fall on his sword and take a felony plea despite the fact that he made no incriminating statements to law enforcement and Mayumi’s statements could not be used against him. Given the marital privilege it is doubtful Mayumi could have been called as a witness against Richard and the rules against hearsay would have prevented the showing of the videotaped statement she made against Richard. Upon reviewing the evidence, arguably, Mayumi could have possibly ended up being deported and Richard could have proceeded to trial and had a good chance at an acquittal. This, however, would have put the family at grave risk of seeing a loving, caring, compassionate wife and mother ripped from the family and deported. That was not an acceptable risk, thus these pleas.


It is supremely ironic that law enforcement has expressed such grave concern over the welfare of the children, but it was ultimately the threat of taking the children’s mother from the family and deporting her to Japan which fueled this deal. Threatening to stretch what is essentially a low level misdemeanor into a felony prosecution followed by deportation upon conviction simply to make a point shows a complete and utter disregard for the true best interests of these children

blog comments powered by Disqus