Foreign Policy

Conor Powell

Afghanistan

11

comments

Pressure On Karzai To Clean Up Government

November 10, 2009 - 1:15 PM | by: Conor Powell

KABUL - At the corner of two unpaved muddy roads in downtown Kabul, Abdul Rahim bakes traditional Afghan bread and complains that life in Afghanistan is becoming more difficult.

"The government is no help. It is corrupt."

Rahim’s view of the Afghan government is not unique. Most Afghans view the government, led by President Hamid Karzai since 2001, as corrupt and ineffective – and many Western officials fear that the Karzai government may not be the viable and credible partner General Stanley McChrystal says is needed to stabilize the war torn nation.

In recent months, violence in Afghanistan has reached record levels and it remains one of the poorest countries in the world – less than 10% of the roads are paved and clean drinking water is rare.

“Despite the influx of billions of dollars in terms of aid and donations,” said Haroun Mir of the Afghanistan Center for Research and Policy Studies, “we see little change in the Afghan villages.”

Afghan police regularly request bribes from drivers at traffic check points and shake down businesses for protection money.

The August 20th Presidential election was marred by wide spread fraud and ballot stuffing – an investigation by a U.N. backed panel ruled more than 1 million of Presidents Karzai’s votes were fake and were later tossed out.

Karzai was declared the winner, after his main challenger, Dr. Abdullah Abdullah, withdrew from the round run-off election claiming the second round would be plagued by the same fraud that marred the first round.

But supporters say the Karzai government has achieved far more than it is given credit for, and blame the media for its poor reputation.

“The international media has focused all on the negative,” said Abdul Rahim Wardak, Afghanistan’s Minister of Defense, “but at the moment the future is quite bright.”

Indeed, millions of children, including women who were banned from receiving an education under the Taliban, now attend school and the economy in the many cities like Kabul and Herat is booming.

Most importantly though, supporters believe Karzai has held the country together during a period of difficult transition by reaching out to various ethnic groups.

Reacting to International pressure, Karzai has pledged to clean up his government.

“Our government’s image has been tainted by corruption,” Karzai told reporters after being declared the winner of the Afghan election, “we will strive by any means possible to eradicate this stain.”

For better or worse, many U.S. and International officials admit privately, there isn’t another viable political alternative to working with Karzai. They hope he can regain the trust he once had.

"I think that the government here does have the potential to be a credible viable partner.” Said Florida Republican Senator George LeMieux, “I think they are working hard to be that."

joseybo

the biggest investigation right now is thw one we should be doing on Obama and his croney staff. They are poisioning the country.

November 11, 2009 at 11:48 AM
Reply

Jerry

We can't even clean up the Obama corruption!

November 11, 2009 at 8:56 AM
Reply

reeder

proofreed, prooofrede, proofread

November 11, 2009 at 8:24 AM
Reply

C. Geisenderfer

I agree that Afghanistan must clean up the corruption there, but am not holding my breath. However I also believe that we need to send more troops in order to provide security, sothat something can be accomplished in the Government there. I am truly grateful for the sacrifice our men and women have made there. I we leave the area, the taliban will move in making room for Al Quaeda to come back and this makes me very afraid for our country.

November 11, 2009 at 6:27 AM
Reply

Husain

It hasn't gotten that bad yet, especially politically speaking it may never get that bad.

November 11, 2009 at 12:03 AM
Reply

Bill

This is almost laughable that we are asking Afghanistan to do something we are unwilling to do here. We need to clean our own house before we demands that of others.

November 10, 2009 at 7:48 PM
Reply

Ozark_Sunshine

Leonard and sniper are 100% correct. Most in Congress have criminal records and it is even worse with Obama, who himself needs to be investigated, and the admin he has put in place.

November 10, 2009 at 5:44 PM
Reply

Leonard

I think the United States Government should get the corruption out of their own government before telling any other country to do the same. Kinda like the pot calling the kettle black. We have so many corrupt politicians wasting and stealing our money that it ain`t even funny. It was real bad under Bush but has gotten horrific under this Comunist Regime that we have now.

November 10, 2009 at 3:46 PM
Reply

sniper

We have the most corrupt govt. in the world and we are telling them to clean theirs up.

November 10, 2009 at 3:35 PM
Reply